Astronomy · Unit 2: History & Tools of Astronomy ·  Problem 2.3.1

Right Tool for the Job

A shelf of instruments, three requests, and not enough time to set them all up  ·  3 in-class days

Pulls TogetherLight-Gathering, Resolution & Spectroscopy

You've volunteered to help run the school's public stargazing night, and the sign-up sheet has three very different requests: someone wants to see "a galaxy, like a really far one," someone wants to see Jupiter's cloud bands up close, and your chemistry teacher wants to know what a particular star is actually made of.

The club's shelf has a real mix of instruments — but only enough time to set up two of them before people start showing up.

Before you can decide what to bring outside, you need to know what each instrument is actually good at — and just as important, what it can't do.

Your Investigation Questions
Q1Which instrument actually resolves each of these three targets?
Q2What's the trade-off between light-gathering power and detail?
Q3How do you defend leaving an instrument behind?

This is the assignment — with your own specific shelf of instruments generated for you on the problem page. Everything in this unit's second half was building toward knowing which tool to reach for, and why.

🧭 Plot Summary

No new content here — this problem is entirely about applying what you already know from Activities 2.2.1 and 2.2.2 and Project 2.2.3 to a real, constrained situation. You'll be handed a specific set of instruments and three fixed requests, with only enough setup time for two of the three tools. It's on you to recommend which two, explain exactly what each one buys you, and defend — in writing — the one you left behind.

Resource Map — where each piece comes from

Stuck on a specific instrument's capabilities? Jump straight to the deep dive that covers it.

✅ Self-Check Before You Roll On

Check off each item as you get there. These aren't grades — they're your own signal.