Astronomy · Unit 5: Galaxies & Cosmology · Problem 5.3.1

The Problem: The Galaxy That Doesn't Add Up

📝 In-Class Problem
3 in-class days. Your galaxy's data, constraints, report requirements, and rubric below.

🎯 Your Galaxy

Loading your observing data…

🔒 Constraints

📋 Deliverable — Your Report Must Include

📊 Grading Rubric — 100 pts

A starting point — adjust weights to fit your class before assigning.

CategoryWeightExemplaryProficientDevelopingIncomplete
Redshift, Velocity & Distance25 ptsCorrect z, recession velocity, and distance (in Mpc and millions of light-years), with every step and formula shown.Method correct; one arithmetic slip or a missing unit.A formula misused or a step skipped, leading to a wrong distance.Calculation missing.
Rotation-Curve Analysis25 ptsCorrectly describes the curve, calculates the expected outer speed from visible matter, and finds the mass ratio and dark-matter share — on an annotated graph.Analysis mostly correct; graph annotations thin or one value off.Describes the curve but doesn't quantify the missing mass.No rotation-curve analysis.
Dark Matter Argument25 ptsA clear claim backed by the student's own numbers plus at least two independent lines of evidence, explained in their own words.Solid claim and data; outside evidence mentioned but not explained.Asserts dark matter without connecting it to the data.No argument.
Alternatives & Assumptions15 ptsTakes on a real alternative (e.g. hidden ordinary matter, measurement error, modified gravity) and explains why the evidence favors dark matter; states at least one assumption made.Names an alternative with thin reasoning.No real alternative or assumption discussed.Missing.
Communication10 ptsOrganized like a real analysis report: clear sections, labeled graph, correct units.Mostly clear with minor gaps.Hard to follow.Not submitted.
← Back to Problem 5.3.1🗺️ Back to Unit 4 Overview

🔭 Problem 5.3.1 · Unit 5 of 6 · Single Semester